Responsible finance serving the general interest

© Philippe Lissac

As part of a report on responsible finance, Admical met in April with Eric Campos, Managing Director of the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation and CSR Director of Crédit Agricole SA. This was an opportunity to discuss the prospects and challenges of the inclusive finance sector. A spotlight on this interview, available in full on Admical.

What is your assessment of the Foundation's first two terms?

The Foundation is a player in inclusive finance that seeks to reconcile economic profitability and social impact. To this end, it pursues a rigorous investment policy that prioritizes both sustainability and positive social externalities. The Foundation integrates financial and social performance at the heart of its investment process.

In 10 years, the Foundation has provided €200 million in financing to 38 countries, including 40% among the least developed countries with a loss rate of less than 0.6%. €200 million of financing has enabled the financing of between 600,000 and 700,000 microloans. More than 80% of microloan beneficiaries are women, and we operate overwhelmingly in rural areas.

In your opinion, how is the responsible finance sector likely to evolve in the coming years?

Responsible finance is a broad concept that covers several definitions, but can be summarized by the practice of the profession aimed at reconciling financial performance and social, environmental, or societal impact. But in reality, we cannot say that there is responsible finance on the one hand and irresponsible finance on the other. In fact, responsible finance is that which integrates this dual concern and explicitly reports. I believe that this way of integrating the effect or externality could gradually become the general rule, even in so-called traditional finance.

Last October, Amundi, the leading European asset manager, decided to integrate ESG factor analysis into all of its funds under management within three years. By integrating these criteria, Amundi clearly illustrates that non-financial criteria are gradually entering the range of assessment criteria for investment funds. This approach clearly demonstrates the dynamic evolution of finance.

A word about the Foundation's next five-year term. What are its major strategic directions?

Climate change, population growth, digital transformation... many challenges are shaking the world of microfinance. There is an urgent need to mobilize resources, innovate with new means of action, and strengthen cooperation. This conviction is at the heart of the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation's actions and its development plan.

The Foundation will continue to adapt to these new challenges by diversifying its expertise and enhancing its intervention methods. These three strategic challenges will guide its actions in the coming years.

Find the full interview with Eric Campos on Admical.

The Foundation publishes its 2018 Integrated Report

© Didier Gentilhomme

The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation has published its 2018 Integrated Report, which highlights key moments, figures, and projects developed with its partners. 2018 was an important year for the Foundation. It marked the Foundation's 10th anniversary with several commemorative events celebrated alongside its partners and founders, Crédit Agricole and Professor Yunus, Nobel Peace Prize winner and founder of the Grameen Trust. Ten years later, the Foundation has positioned itself as a recognized player in the inclusive finance sector and is strengthening its efforts to contribute to the fight against poverty.

2018 was also a year of growth. As of December 31, 2018, the Foundation managed €73 million in outstanding loans and supported more than 70 partners in 34 countries in Africa, Asia, and Europe. At the heart of its objectives, the Foundation promotes women's entrepreneurship and rural economies through the institutions it supports: 751,300 microcredit beneficiaries are women, and 801,300 live in rural areas.

2018 was also a strong year for partnerships. Several projects were launched with the Crédit Agricole Group: the development of cooperation schemes with the Group's international entities, the launch of FIR, the Group's first microfinance fund, and the establishment of "Solidarity Banker," a skills volunteer program open to all Group employees on behalf of the Foundation's partners.

2018 was also the year of preparation of the Foundation's 2019-2022 Strategic Plan, which confirms the Foundation's commitment to strengthening the microfinance sector, developing rural economies and promoting impact finance.

To download the 2018 Integrated Report, click here.

 

The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation publishes its 2019-2022 strategic plan

© Didier Gentilhomme

La parution du Plan stratégique 2019-2022 ancre le positionnement de la Fondation autour de trois axes prioritaires : consolider notre expertise et notre offre en faveur de la microfinance, renforcer la résilience des économies rurales et promouvoir l’impact social dans le secteur financier.

Créée en 2008 par l’initiative conjointe des dirigeants de Crédit Agricole S.A. et du Prix Nobel de la Paix 2006 et fondateur de la Grameen Trust, le Pr. Muhammad Yunus, la Fondation Grameen Crédit Agricole s’engage dans la promotion de la microfinance et de l’entrepreneuriat à impact social. Avec plus de 200 millions d’euros de financements accordés en prêts et investissements, une présence dans une quarantaine des pays et un réseau de plus de 100 partenaires soutenus depuis l’origine, la Fondation représente pour le groupe Crédit Agricole un pôle de spécialité unique dans le domaine de la finance inclusive dans les pays émergents.

Over the past ten years, the Foundation has acquired solid experience in financing microfinance institutions and promoting rural economic development. It has developed several projects with Crédit Agricole Group entities and Regional Banks: through cooperation schemes with the Group's international entities, a skills volunteer program, and a social impact investment fund, the Foundation has been able to strengthen its action and multiply its impact.

To address the challenges ahead and make a positive contribution, the Foundation's team developed the 2019-2022 strategic plan in 2018 with the help of the Board of Directors and in consultation with external partners and stakeholders. The three pillars proposed in the strategic plan (strengthening support for MFIs, developing the resilience of rural economies, and promoting social impact in the financial sector) are based on the Foundation's strengths and strategic axes that aim to strengthen its positioning, increase its impact, and balance its business model.

To discover the 2019-2022 strategic plan, click here.

 

Solidarity Bankers Missions in Senegal, Cambodia and Kenya

© Philippe Lissac

Solidarity Banker is a new type of volunteer mission abroad offered to Group employees on behalf of microfinance institutions or social impact companies, partners of the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation. Three missions are available: one "digital" in Senegal, one "HR/management" in Cambodia, and one "strategy" in Kenya.

The missions to be filled

A "digital" mission for Kossam in Senegal is planned for June-July 2019. Kossam is a social enterprise whose mission is to develop and establish an inclusive and sustainable dairy sector around Richard Toll, in northern Senegal. To achieve this, Kossam collects milk from 450 local farmers, provides them with marketing services, and provides advice and training. The Solidarity Banker will be responsible for supporting Kossam in the deployment of a digital application, "commcare collection."

An HR/management mission is planned for the second quarter of 2019 to support Cirque Phare (PPSE) in Cambodia. PPSE provides employment opportunities for Cambodian artists and sustains the country's arts sector. PPSE has now entered a growth phase and requires strengthening certain aspects of its management, particularly in terms of strategy, finance, and human resources. The Solidarity Banker will be responsible for proposing monitoring tools and making recommendations on the organizational structure.

A strategy mission for ACRE Africa in Kenya will take place in the second/third quarter of 2019. Based in Kenya, but also present in Tanzania and Rwanda, ACRE Africa offers crop insurance services to smallholder farmers. ACRE decided in 2018 to diversify its activities to offer consulting services and to change its business model, moving from a B to C model to a B to B model. The Solidarity Banker will be responsible for analyzing the organization's new strategy and evaluating its business model.

How to apply?

– Go to the CA Solidaires website “Find your mission”
– Enter “Grameen Foundation” in the search bar. All Solidarity Leave offers will appear!
– Click on the offer of your choice, you will find all the information necessary for your application.

More information: carolina.herrera@credit-agricole-sa.fr

Inclusive Finance at Harvard Business School

By Hélène Keraudren Baube, Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation

© Harvard Business School

Led by Harvard Business School and ACCION, the Strategic Leadership in Inclusive Finance Program is an intensive five-day course designed to reflect on the sector's progress and challenges. This year, Hélène Keraudren-Baube, Administrative and Financial Director of the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, had the opportunity to participate thanks to a scholarship awarded by InFiNe Luxembourg. Here's a look back at this immersive week.

There were around sixty of us participants, from all continents and, above all, from varied backgrounds: microfinance practitioners, investors and donors, financial service providers, regulators, etc. The program is structured around a series of case studies and guided discussions, with a very large place given to digital finance – a theme that has now become essential for microfinance institutions.

Day 1: Financial inclusion in question

Our first working session aimed to introduce the topic of financial inclusion with case studies on public-private partnerships led by Mastercard in South Africa and Nigeria. Mastercard introduced its cards into government programs to, in the South African case, help dematerialize the payment of government benefits, and in the Nigerian case, provide ID documents to people who did not have them. However, in South Africa, most customers continue to prefer cash and see no real benefit from having a card. In Nigeria, very few people have sought out ID cards, as the process of obtaining them was quite cumbersome and tedious. We thus come to see that pushing technology does not lead to financial inclusion: for inclusion to be effective, solutions must be tailored to end users.

Day 2: Changes in the microfinance sector

Our second day of work focused on the changes we are observing in the traditional microfinance sector. In some markets, such as Peru, we are seeing a shift towards mergers and acquisitions between microfinance institutions. In others, such as Bolivia, we are seeing microfinance institutions having to adapt to regulatory changes. More recently, we are seeing the arrival of digitalization as a new phenomenon to which MFIs must adapt: how is technology affecting internal processes, product distribution, payments, and credit scoring? An interesting discussion that also raised other questions: Are client needs still a priority? Is client interaction preserved?

Day 3: What are the prospects for fintechs?

We continued our training with another series of cases on the arrival of Fintechs in the landscape. We studied an Indian system, where mobile payment providers are growing so much that they have replaced cash in many daily transactions. The corollary is that, in doing so, these operators are collecting masses of data on their customers, leading us to ask ourselves: while creating a digital footprint may seem like a good thing, how can we ensure the responsible use and processing of customer data? In China, we examined a peer-to-peer platform created to allow individuals to finance micro-entrepreneurs. The platform managed to grow very quickly and reach millions of people, going far beyond its initial model. How should we regulate such platforms, which have proliferated in China in recent years?

Fintechs are therefore emerging as disruptors of inclusive finance because they create unprecedented opportunities. They are changing the ecosystem and are capable of evolving rapidly, but if we want Fintechs to be part of financial inclusion, we must put customers at the center of our concerns.

The detailed report by Hélène Keraudren Baube is available on the InFiNe Luxembourg website.

[Webinar] What are the profitability levels for microfinance?

© Didier Gentilhomme

On April 9, Philippe Guichandut, Director of Inclusive Finance Development at the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, participated in a webinar organized by Convergences and FinDev Gateway. The goal of this webinar was to reflect on the profitability of microfinance, focusing on three key issues: Why invest in microfinance? What balance should be struck between financial profitability and social performance? How can a business model be developed to reconcile dual profitability?

Although an essential requirement, the notion of profitability is nevertheless complex to grasp in a sector like microfinance, whose raison d'être is social impact. Thus, must microfinance necessarily be profitable? If so, can it be so while remaining socially responsible? Can it remain faithful to its aspirations and contribute, through financial inclusion, to lifting 1.7 billion people worldwide without access to banking services out of poverty? Between reasonable interest rates and sufficient profitability, what balance can microfinance institutions strike? What resources are available to finance the development of the microfinance sector?

This is what the various guest speakers attempted to answer. Also present alongside Philippe Guichandut were Gabriela Erice Garcia, Senior Microfinance Officer at the European Microfinance Platform (e-MFP), and Frédéric Mille, Investment Director at Advans International.

The Foundation and the EIB join forces to promote microfinance in Africa

© FGCA

On April 1, the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation and the European Investment Bank (EIB) held a roundtable discussion in Paris on the topic of developing rural economies and strengthening microfinance in Africa through the EIB. Representatives of both institutions shared a common goal: promoting a more sustainable and inclusive economy.

Following the EIB's granting of a €12 million loan equivalent in CFA francs to the Foundation to support microfinance in West Africa, this roundtable also provided an opportunity to discuss issues related to the development of rural areas in Africa. Several guests gathered to discuss rural microfinance, agriculture, gender, and climate change.

For the Foundation, recognition of expertise in microfinance

As Jérôme Brunel, Foundation Administrator and General Secretary of Crédit Agricole SA, recalled in his opening speech, the Foundation has lent more than four times its capital in the space of 10 years, representing €200 million in financing, for a presence in around thirty countries and more than 100 partners supported since 2008. At the end of 2018, the Foundation recorded an outstanding amount of €76 million and supported 75 partners in 35 countries. After excellent results in 2018, this new financing will therefore allow the Foundation to expand its action in Africa in the field of microfinance and support for social entrepreneurship. "With this financing granted to the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, the European Investment Bank confirms its commitment to financial inclusion in West Africa alongside a committed player that has just celebrated its 10th anniversary," said Ambroise Fayolle, Vice-President of the EIB.

Mamadou Lamine Gueye, Managing Director of Caurie Microfinance, a Senegalese microfinance institution partnering with the Foundation and a beneficiary of the EIB loan, and Soukeyna Ndiaye Bâ, Managing Director of the INAFI International Foundation and a director of the Foundation, spoke of the importance of intermediaries such as the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation, whose positioning makes it possible to finance small microfinance institutions that would otherwise not be eligible for funding from major donors. Both agreed to recognize the role of the Foundation and other donors in developing the microfinance sector on the continent, thereby providing opportunities for African youth.

Two institutions have already benefited from the EIB loan to the Foundation: Caurie Microfinance, whose mission is the social and economic empowerment of poor microentrepreneurs in Senegal, primarily women; and PAMF BF, which offers microcredits to finance agricultural and economic activities such as market gardening and grain production in Burkina Faso. These two institutions alone represent more than 110,000 active borrowers, including 79,87% women.

Africa, a priority target for the Foundation

Sub-Saharan Africa accounts for approximately 301,000 million of the Foundation's funding. The Foundation focuses its efforts there on behalf of rural populations, with the aim of strengthening the resilience of the agricultural sector. "The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation is now present in a dozen African countries," emphasized Jean-Marie Sander, President of the Foundation. For Eric Campos, General Delegate of the Foundation, "working on agriculture means working on the future of Africa. We must unleash the development of products adapted to the rural world: today, agriculture represents 601,000 million of the continent's workforce. Yet farmers represent only 31,000 million of bank exhibitors!"

In line with the Foundation's work, microfinance is a fundamental pillar of value creation in Africa. This is also what two of our speakers, Flora Helard and Mathilde Thonon, students at Sciences Po Paris and co-founders of In-Venture, observed on the ground. They spent a year in West Africa and Southeast Asia meeting those who find solutions to their communities' social and environmental problems in finance. In particular, they met with two of the Foundation's partner MFIs in Benin: RENACA and ACFB. Their enthusiasm reflects the performance of a dynamic sector that attracts the young entrepreneurs of tomorrow.

The Foundation makes five investments in Africa

© Didier Gentilhomme

Au cours du premier trimestre 2019, la Fondation Grameen Crédit Agricole a intensifié sa présence auprès de ses partenaires africains avec l’octroi de 5 nouveaux financements, notamment sous la forme de prêts senior. A fin mars 2019, compte 40 partenaires en Afrique Subsaharienne, ce qui représente 42% de l’encourt total.

The Foundation thus granted, as part of the African Facility program, a local currency loan equivalent to €800,000 to the microfinance institution Eclof Kenya, which offers financial and non-financial services to micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises in the country, while actively promoting savings. To date, the institution, which finances 58% of women, has more than 30,000 clients, 60% in rural areas.

Also in East Africa, the Foundation also granted a new loan in local currency equivalent to €1 million to UGAFODE, a Ugandan microfinance institution whose primary mission is to provide its clients with affordable primary financial services. The institution currently has 17,300 clients, including nearly 201,000 women and approximately 801,000 rural clients.

In West Africa, the Foundation granted a new loan to the Togolese microfinance institution Coopec Sifa for €305,000 in local currency. Coopec Sifa, which is financed under the African Facility, is a microfinance institution that offers small loans to its nearly 38,000 clients, primarily women (86%) in the north of the country.

In addition, ACEP Burkina was also granted a new loan of €2.3 million in CFA francs. This microfinance institution, a partner of the Foundation since 2016, specializes in financing microenterprises and very small businesses in urban centers and inner suburbs. It currently has 12,300 clients, including 20% women.

Finally, in Senegal, the Foundation strengthened its partnership with Laiterie du Berger, in which it has been a shareholder since 2010, by granting a loan in the form of a shareholder current account, for an amount in CFA francs equivalent to 229,000 euros. Laiterie du Berger is a social enterprise that recycles milk collected from Fulani herders in the north of the country, transforming it into yogurts and other dairy products sold under the Dolima brand.

To learn more about the Foundation's partners, click here.

EIB grants €12 million loan to Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation

© EIB

The Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation has received a €12 million loan from the European Investment Bank (EIB) equivalent in CFA francs to support the development of microfinance in West Africa. This funding in local currency is a true recognition for the Foundation, which will be able to expand its presence in Africa.

The EIB, a committed player in microfinance

The EIB has extensive experience in developing microfinance. With over €1.3 billion committed since its first microfinance operations in 1992, it supports microfinance institutions and other sector stakeholders promoting inclusive and responsible finance. Under the Cotonou Agreement signed in 2000 between the European Union and the ACP (African, Caribbean, and Pacific) group of countries, the EIB launched a Microfinance Investment Facility to promote the private sector and combat poverty in West African countries. It was under this program that a €12 million loan, equivalent in CFA francs, was granted to the Grameen Crédit Agricole Foundation.

The Foundation, an expert in the sector

As an investor, financier, technical assistance coordinator, and fund advisor, the Foundation has been supporting microfinance and social business institutions around the world for 10 years. Ten years later, it has raised more than €200 million in financing, a presence in some thirty countries, and more than 100 partners supported since its inception. In 2018, the Foundation managed €73 million in outstanding loans, and supported 75 partners in 35 countries. Following its successful results in 2018, this new funding will allow the Foundation to expand its work in Africa around microfinance and support for social entrepreneurship.

With more than 30% of financing in sub-Saharan Africa, the Foundation is positioning itself as a committed player in the fight against poverty on the continent. It focuses its action on rural populations to support financial inclusion and strengthen the resilience of the agricultural sector. This alliance between the EIB and the Foundation meets a common objective: to finance and promote a more sustainable and inclusive economy, in line with the Global Development Agenda by 2030. By providing this financing in CFA francs, the EIB allows the Foundation to continue supporting its partners in West Africa with loans in local currency.

Projects already underway

Two institutions will already benefit from this joint support: CAURIE MICROFINANCE in Senegal, which contributes sustainably to the social and economic empowerment of poor micro-entrepreneurs, primarily women; and PAM BF in Burkina Faso, which provides microcredit to finance agricultural and economic activities, such as market gardening and grain production. These two institutions have nearly 100,000 active borrowers between them.

 » Avec ce financement, la Banque européenne d’investissement confirme son engagement en faveur de l’inclusion financière en Afrique de l’Ouest aux côtés d’un acteur engagé qui vient de célébrer ses 10 ans d’existence », a expliqué Ambroise Fayolle, Vice-président de la BEI. « La capacité à financer cette opération en monnaie locale est un élément clé pour pouvoir atteindre les populations les plus fragiles sans faire peser le risque de change sur les institutions de microfinance. Nous soutenons particulièrement la Fondation Grameen Crédit Agricole sur sa démarche en faveur de l’emploi des femmes. Ce sont ces valeurs portées par l’Europe que nous soutenons aujourd’hui.  »

 » Le prêt de la BEI nous permet de démultiplier l’action de la Fondation qui concentre plus d’un tiers de ses financements en Afrique subsaharienne et est présente dans une douzaine des pays africains. L’Afrique continuera d’être une cible prioritaire pour la Fondation qui concentrera d’ici 2022 plus de 30% de ses financements dans le continent. Merci à la BEI de faire partie de l’aventure humaine et entrepreneuriale que le Crédit Agricole et le Professeur Yunus ont commencé il y a 10 ans. « , a déclaré Jean-Marie Sander, Président de la Fondation Grameen Crédit Agricole.

Philippe Guichandut spoke at the Bank of France

©Philippe Lissac / Godong

Du 11 au 15 mars dernier, la Banque de France organisait le séminaire « Protection du consommateur, inclusion et éducation financières ». Ce séminaire avait pour objectif de mettre en avant les missions assurées par une banque centrale en matière de protection du consommateur de services financiers, d’inclusion et d’éducation financières. Ces missions visent à améliorer l’information du consommateur, à lui apporter une assistance en cas de difficultés, ou à prévenir ces dernières ou y remédier. Généralement exercées en application de textes législatifs et réglementaires spécifiques à chaque pays, ces activités ont été comparées avec l’approche adoptée dans ce domaine par d’autres banques centrales.

The topics covered were:

– Control of the commercial practices of banks and insurance companies,
– General presentation of the role of the Banque de France in the area of relations between individuals and the financial sphere and the legal protection provisions,
– The organization of relations between the banking sector and consumer organizations,
– Files of general interest managed by the Banque de France and concerning individuals,
– Public information and banking mediation in France,
– The treatment of household over-indebtedness,
– Financial inclusion and financial education.

Des tables rondes ont été organisées afin de permettre des échanges d’informations et d’expériences entre les participants, notamment au travers de courtes présentations de leur problématique nationale. C’est ainsi que Philippe Guichandut, Directeur Développement de la Finance Inclusive à la Fondation Grameen Crédit Agricole, a été invité à intervenir et à présenter l’action de la Fondation, avant d’échanger avec les autres invités sur leurs meilleures pratiques.